The Islander Star Best of AMI Award logo

Restaurants & Dining

Seafood pasta dish at Isola Bella Italian Eatery in Manatee, FL

7 Special Restaurants in Anna Maria Island that Take Online Reservations

Anna Maria Island is an ideal vacation destination for mingling with locals and visiting charming shops and restaurants. Anna Maria is known for its delicious food, and thanks to online reservations, it’s easier than ever to grab a table. Here Read More

Popular dish from Freckled Fin Irish Pub in Anna Maria Island, FL

The Best Irish Pub in Anna Maria Island

Though Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem in Florida, it definitely has distinct qualities that it is known for. The laid-back atmosphere is the Island’s main attraction, allowing visitors to truly get away from the hustle and bustle of Read More

eat here restaurant menu in anna maria island

Best Meatloaf in Anna Maria Island

Vacation is the time for rest and relaxation in every form, from soaking up the sun on the beach to indulging in some of your favorite comfort foods. While you may immediately think of the Florida seafood as your best Read More

Hometown Desserts in Anna Maria Island makes custom cakes sold in local restaurants

3 Best Bakeries in Anna Maria Island

Fine sweets and fluffy bread, it is what island living is all about. While Anna Maria Island has plenty of fun things to do for kids and adults alike, few are as universal as eating a good sweet from a Read More

Baked Ziti in Anna Maria Island

How to Find the Best Baked Ziti in Anna Maria Island

Where is the best ziti in Anna Maria Island? Is it tucked away on a sea shanty by the water? Is it right by the grand city pier, next to an ice cream shop and an old book store? Could Read More

Salmon dish from The Sign of the Mermaid Restaurant in Anna Maria Island

3 Signature Dishes at the Sign of the Mermaid Restaurant

Sophisticated yet casual, flexible yet focused, the Sign of the Mermaid is one of the most alluring and interesting Anna Maria Island seafood restaurants. Hidden within this small but elegant eatery is a fine selection of local seafood dishes, delightful Read More

What to Eat When You Visit Vinny and Cheryl’s Italian Kitchen

What to Eat When You Visit Vinny and Cheryl’s Italian Kitchen

If you’re looking for one of the best Italian restaurants in Florida, look no further than Vinny and Cheryl’s Italian Kitchen on Pine Avenue on Anna Maria Island near our vacation rentals. This classic Italian Restaurant offers plenty of Italian Read More

3 Signature Dishes at the Rod and Reel Pier Restaurant || Vacation Rentals on AMI || Florida Dreams

3 Signature Dishes at the Rod and Reel Pier Restaurant

Once a local secret, The Rod & Reel Pier Restaurant is one of the more popular Anna Maria Island restaurants. It’s the perfect spot to get traditional fish and seafood specials – a little taste of Old Florida. The Rod Read More

Romantic restaurants on Anna Maria Island

5 Romantic Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

No matter where you live, visiting Anna Maria Island is ideal for a romantic getaway with so many things to do, white sand beaches to relax on, and pleasant weather most of the year. Anna Maria Island is the definitive Read More


Best Places to Eat in Bradenton Beach

Looking to dine out at some exquisite restaurants during your vacation on Anna Maria Island? No matter what type of cuisine you’re looking to indulge in, there’s plenty for you to choose from in nearby Bradenton, located in mainland Florida Read More